With the cost of food soaring, many people are worried about the price of their Christmas food shop.
Most UK supermarkets offer loyalty schemes to entice customers, from Sainsbury’s Nectar card to M&S’ Sparks card offering – but which actually provide shoppers with the most competitive benefits?
The financial experts at Moneyboat.co.uk sought to find out which UK supermarkets offer their customers the best reward schemes, and which offer the least benefits.
The team created an index by gathering information on various aspects provided by each scheme, such as joining fees, exclusive discounts, free delivery, personalised offers, coupons provided and more, for the following supermarkets: Marks and Spencer, Co-op, Asda, Tesco, Sainsburys, Morrisons, Waitrose, and Iceland. Furthermore, Moneyboat.co.uk conducted a survey asking 3,576 Brits how satisfied they are with each rewards scheme and what is most important to them when using it.
RESULTS
Please see the full index results here.
The supermarket with the best rewards scheme is Tesco!
The study reveals that the supermarket with the best rewards scheme overall is Tesco, with a score of 99 out of 100. How did Tesco get such a high score, you may ask? The shop’s Clubcard is free to join, it offers exclusive discounts, coupons and a points scheme. Not only that, but the Tesco Clubcard also offers savings on petrol, it has transportation and entertainment partners where you can get further discounts, you have the ability to use it for charity donations and it can be used at other retailers. Furthermore, Tesco’s Clubcard has a customer satisfaction scoreof 3.82/5, the highest out of all supermarkets!
In second place is Sainsbury’s Nectar card with an overall score of 88 out of 100. Sainsbury’s rewards scheme is free to join, offers exclusive discounts to customers, as well as personalised offers, coupons and points scheme for their Nectar card owners.
Just like Tesco’s Clubcard, Sainsbury’s Nectar card offers savings on petrol, it has transportation and entertainment partners where you can get discounts, you have the ability to use it for charity donations and it can be used at other retailers.
However, when it comes to customer satisfaction score, Sainsbury rates only 2.58 out of 5 as the majority of people (37% of the survey respondents) said they are somewhat satisfied with the Nectar card.
CO-OP’s Membership offers the best pound to credit conversion
In third place we have the CO-OP’s Membership with a score of 84 out of 100. What makes this rewards scheme special? Their points scheme translates to apound to credit conversion of 2% (percentage of money translated into buying power), the highest out of all supermarkets. Furthermore, the CO-OP got a customer satisfaction score of 3.25 out of 5.
Asda’s Rewards scheme comes in fourth place with a score of 57 out of 100. People using this rewards scheme are getting the following benefits: no joining fee, coupons, savings on petrol and it can be used at other retailers. Based on the survey, the Rewards scheme has a customer satisfaction score of 3.80 out of 5, second biggest behind Tesco.
In fifth place is Lidl’s Lidle Plus with a score of 56 out of 100. With a customer satisfaction score of 3.06 out of 5, the rewards scheme is free to join, and it offers exclusive discounts, coupons, savings on petrol, it can be used at other retailers, including entertainment partners.
Shop at Iceland if you want free delivery as part of your rewards scheme!
Iceland’s Bonus Card comes in sixth place with an overall score of 51 out of 100. The Bonus Card scheme is free to join and is the only one to offer customers free delivery or C&C. Equally in sixth place we have Marks and Spencer’s Sparks, with an overall score of 51 out of 100. The Sparks gives customers the following benefits: no joining fee, exclusive discounts, personalised offers, coupons, and charity donations. Marks and Spencer’s Sparks has a customer satisfaction score of 3 out of 5.
The supermarkets with the worst rewards schemes are Waitrose and Morrisons
We have made it to the bottom two, and equally in seventh place we have Waitroseand Morrisons, both scoring 40 out of 100 points. The reward schemes for both shops are free to join. Their benefits include discounts, personalised offers and coupons; however, they don’t include most of the benefits the other shops provide for their rewards schemes.
What benefits do customers find most important in rewards schemes?
| What is most important to you when using supermarket loyalty schemes? | % |
| Exclusive immediate discounts on products | 38% |
| Instant money off vouchers | 27% |
| That rewards are personalised to you | 11% |
| The ability to gather points | 10% |
| Savings on fuel | 6% |
| Rewards can be used at other shops (i.e. Nectar) | 5% |
| Free delivery or click and collect | 3% |
Please see the full survey results here.
The survey shows that Exclusive immediate discounts on products is the benefit people find most important when using a supermarket rewards scheme. In fact, a whopping 38% said that’s what they appreciate most in a rewards scheme. Luckily all supermarkets apart from Asda offer that.
In second place is Instant money off vouchers with 27% of people saying they find that very important in a loyalty scheme. In fact, all supermarkets but Iceland offer vouchers to the customers using their rewards scheme.
Personalised rewards come in third place with 11%. The Supermarkets that offer personalised rewards are Sainsbury, the CO-OP, Marks and Spencer, Waitrose and Morrisons.
The ability to gather points comes in fourth place with 10% and the only supermarkets that offer that benefit with their rewards schemes are Tesco, Sainsburys, and the CO-OP.
In fifth place we have savings on fuel with 6% (Tesco, Sainsbury, Asda and Lidl), followed by the ability for rewards to be used in other shops with 5% (also Tesco, Sainsbury, Asda and Lidl).
Lastly, 3% of people said they’d appreciate it if their rewards scheme would offer free delivery and collection. The only supermarket that offers that is Iceland.
–
Methodology:
- Moneyboat.co.uk wanted to know which supermarket reward scheme in the UK gave customers the best deal on their groceries.
- Marks and Spencer, the Co-op, Asda, Tesco, Sainsburys, Morrisons, Lidl, Waitrose, and Iceland were the supermarkets used in the study.
- The team then gathered information on various aspects of each scheme, such as whether or not the scheme was free to join, whether or not exclusive discounts were offered, free delivery, personalised offers, coupons provided, points scheme, pound to credit (%), savings on petrol, the ability for points to be used at other retailers, transportation rewards partners, charity donations, entertainment offers, and a customer satisfaction score (based of survey).
- An index score with asymmetric weights applied to each variable was then calculated. A greater weight was given to factors like savings on a typical basket and free delivery.
- The data was then weighted to generate a score out of 100.
- Following the collection of all data, the supermarket rewards schemes were ranked from highest to lowest, resulting in a list of the best loyalty scheme rewards in the UK.
- Furthermore, Moneyboat.co.uk conducted a survey asking 3,576 Brits how satisfied they are with each rewards scheme and what is most important to them when using it.
- Data was collected on 07/11/2022 and is accurate as of then.
